When Esav finds out that Yaakov stole the brachos, we hear about his great, anguished cry, vayitzak ze’aka gedola umara. Interestingly, we find the very same words used in Megillas Esther to describe Mordechai’s anguished cry when he learned about the terrible decree against the Jewish people. The Midrash teaches that Mordechai’s anguished cry was connected to the cry that Yaakov had caused Esav so many generations earlier. But why should Mordechai, a descendant of Yaakov, have to suffer because of Esav’s anguish? After all, wasn’t Yaakov right to take the brachos?
It was fully true and correct for Yaakov to take the brachos from Esav, and it is also true that a descendant of Yaakov, further down the line, was going to have to atone for the anguish caused to Esav. We can hold on to two truths at the same time. There are storylines we understand, and there are bigger storylines that we need to stretch to understand, or may never understand. But we, the descendants of Yaakov, are bigger than one simple narrative, descriptor, or perspective. As the great menagen of our generation, Hanan Ben Ari, says, “אל תכלאוני בשום כלוב” “Don’t imprison me in any one particular cage.” We are big enough to hold multiple perspectives and sit with the tension of the dialectic.
The best bumper sticker I’ve seen driving around Israel says, “Al tihiyeh tzodek, tihiyeh tzaddik.” Don’t focus on being “right”; focus on doing what is righteous. This is such a helpful perspective in any scenario that is causing us agmas nefesh, because the grievance may be “true,” but we can look for a “bigger truth” to latch on to.
I think about this when encountering the infamous man cold. There seems to be a universal, good-natured frustration from wives who often push through all their physical symptoms to keep taking care of their family’s needs and are baffled and annoyed at the seemingly “no big deal” cold of their husbands that somehow cripples them. My husband laughs when he describes just how debilitating the “man cold” can get by telling me about his friend’s father, who, when he gets a cold, actually begins to limp around the house.
Tzodek or tzaddik. A wife has a “truth” and a “bigger truth” ahead of her that she can choose.
It may be true that she needs more help, she needs to feel more appreciated, and that he is not actually as sick as he thinks he is, but there’s also a bigger truth to consider. What type of relationship do I want to be in? What is the climate of the home I want? What type of wife do I want to be, irrespective of my judgments of who is deserving? Do I want to be right about the fact that this person can technically get out of bed and continue to function, or do I want to have the caring type of relationship, with love and support, that truly allows space for the other person’s experience?
It’s nice to be right. It’s nicer to be righteous, to choose the bigger path that accommodates others and their needs and perspectives. We know how to navigate this from Yaakov himself, who represents emes, even though his acts of trickery and deception are part and parcel of his journey in life. Yaakov’s middah is the middle ground between the two polar sides of Avraham’s chesed and Yitzchak’s gevurah. Binah says, “This, not that,” and chochmah says, “This, and also that.” Tiferes can modulate between the two. Let’s be a people capable of living by the truth while also stretching to accommodate bigger truths.
This article was found in Nekuda Tova Issue 106.