אין עוד מלבדו

June 14, 2025

In honor of the 204th yahrtzeit of Rav Chaim Volozhiner, 14 Sivan

The Gemarah (Chulin 7b) tells the story of a woman who would try to take dust from beneath the feet of Rebbi Chanina, in order to perform sorcery to harm him. Renni Chanina told her “Take the dust, but what you are trying to do will be ineffective, as it is written: Ein Od Milvado, there is none other besides for Hashem.” The Gemarah then points out that the Hebrew root word for sorcery, כישופים, indicates that sorcery has the ability to contradict and diminish the Heavenly world, indicating that they function contrary to the Will of Hashem. The Gemarah concludes that Rebbi Chanina is different, because of his great merit, sorcery has no effect on him. 

Rav Chaim of Volzhin, in his sefer Nefesh Hachaim (Shaar 3, Ch. 12)  expounds on this gemarah. Does it mean to say that Rav Chanina would have been harmed by this sorcery, and was saved because of his great merits? Certainly R’ Chanina himself would not have been so confident in his own merits, due to his humility. So how did his mention of “Ein Od Milvado” prevent him from being harmed, and why was he so confident it would work to protect him?

The Nefesh Hachaim explains that the impure powers of sorcery do not operate on their own powers, and have no ability to contradict or diminish the Will of Hashem. Rather, they derive their existence only from Hashem Himself, just like every other reality in the universe. Nothing at all, even the impure forces of Kishuf, can harm anything if it is not the Will of Hashem. 

R’ Chanina was not relying on the merits of his Torah and mitzvos, but rather he was establishing within his heart the absolute belief that nothing exists outside of Hashem, Ein Od Milvado, and therefore this sorcery cannot harm him by its own accord. He told her “Your efforts will not succeed,” you have no ability on your own to harm me and therefore I am not concerned about your attempts at sorcery, because there is nothing besides Hashem!

The Nefesh Hachaim proceeds to tell each and every one of us that what R’ Chanina did to prevent harm to him is a strategy that every single Yid can employ at any moment of danger. In his powerful words:

ובאמת הוא ענין גדול וסגולה נפלאה להסר ולבטל מעליו כל דינין ורצונות אחרים שלא יוכלו לשלוט בו ולא יעשו שום רושם כלל. כשהאדם קובע בלבו לאמר הלא ה’ הוא האלקים האמתי ואין עוד מלבדו יתברך שום כח בעולם וכל העולמות כלל והכל מלא רק אחדותו הפשוט ית”ש. ומבטל בלבו ביטול גמור ואינו משגיח כלל על שום כח ורצון בעולם. ומשעבד ומדבק טוהר מחשבתו רק לאדון יחיד ב”ה. כן יספיק הוא יתב’ בידו שממילא יתבטלו מעליו כל הכחות והרצונות שבעולם שלא יוכלו לפעול לו שום דבר כלל

“This is a wondrous strategy to remove and nullify from oneself any judgment and negative thoughts so they cannot rule over him and cannot have any effect whatsoever. One should establish in his heart and internalize: “Is it not so that Hashem is our true G-d, and there is nothing else in the universe besides Him,and the entirety of existence and all of the spiritual worlds are simply filled completely with the absolute and  unified Presence of Hashem.” One should nullify the powers that can cause danger with an absolute nullification. Do not pay attention to them or give them any value, but rather, focus intensely to attach the purity of your mind to think only of the single Creator of the world. 

Hashem will then ensure that the dangers such a person has encountered will cease to exist, and will be unable to act against him whatsoever.”

Rav Reuven Leuchter, in his commentary on Nefesh Hachaim, Meshivas Nefesh, questions how we can conclude from the story of Rav Chanina that his method of using Ein Od Milvado is something every Yid can use. Yes, it seems clear that this strategy utilizes a method of nullifying danger that is not dependent on merits, so even though we aren’t full of merits like Rav Chanina, we can engage in his method. But there is a strong difference between the danger that Rav Chanina was preventing—which was from impure spiritual forces—and preventing a danger that is being threatened by another person. We can understand how Ein Od Milvado nullifies forces of evil, but how can it nullify the threatening plans of another human being? What makes the emunah of one person overpower the evil plan of another?

Rav Leuchter answers:

“It seems that through a Yid’s complete emunah in Ein Od Milvado, that person himself becomes a place where Hashem’s absolute Oneness is revealed. This Yid is now a physical manifestation of the fact that Hashem’s Presence fills the entirety of the universe. Once you have a space that reveals this lofty truth, that space becomes a representation of that truth and is therefore untouchable by any evil forces—even one that is being planned by another person.”

He compares this to the modern concept of an embassy, where the law is that the location of a nation’s embassy in a foreign country is lawfully considered to be part of that country, even though it can be thousands of miles away and is smack in the middle of a foreign land. When a Yid lives Ein Od Milvado, he becomes an embassy of Hashem—and even if he is in the middle of a ‘foreign land,’ threatened by others, he cannot be harmed!

This strategy of nullifying potential harm through the power of Ein Of Milvado has a long history of making miracles. Rabbi Feuer writes in the Artscroll commentary on the Igeres HaRamban:

“The Brisker Rav, Rav Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik, was a descendant of Rav Chaim of Volozhin — the author of the Nefesh hachaim.

He testified how the statement of faith recorded in the Nefesh hachaim literally served as a guide through his life. When he was a young man, Reb Velvel, as he was called, was commanded to appear before the Russian draft board to be inducted in the Czar’s army. This fate was tantamount to both a spiritual and physical death sentence.

As the date of his appearance neared, his father, Rav Chaim Brisker, instructed him to concentrate on the above passage from the Nefesh hachaim. To Reb Velvel’s great relief, his meeting with the draft board came, and he was exempted from the draft.

Later, when the Germans occupied Poland at the beginning of World War Two, Rev Velvel fled from Warsaw to Vilna. The roads were filled with German troops, and Nazis were everywhere. The danger was awesome. Yet, Reb Velvel traveled along undaunted, for he never stopped reviewing the pledge of the Nefesh hachaim. “If you always think of Hashem. He will always think of you and protect you from all harm.

Just once, Reb Velvel was distracted and his mind wondered onto another thought. Immediately, as if from nowhere, an armed Nazi approached him threateningly. In a flash, Reb Velvel collected his thoughts and focused on the Nefesh hachaim and the Nazi moved on.”

Rabbi Yosef Leib Bloch of Telshe explains that natural forces which threaten mankind can be compared to a vicious dog with a long leash tied to its neck. When the animal pounces, the only way an intended victim can save himself is by calling to the dog’s master, to restrain the beast. If the victim fails to recognize the presence of the master, then he is truly in grave danger. Similarly when man fails to perceive the “leash” upon the forces of nature, he indeed places himself at their mercy.

This article was found in Nekuda Tova Issue 39.

Next up